Global Business, 3rd Edition Mike Peng solutions manual and test bank
Chapter 2
UNDERSTANDING
FORMAL INSTITUTIONS:
POLITICS,
LAWS, AND ECONOMICS
Learning
Objectives
After
studying this chapter, you should be able to:
- explain the
concept of institutions and their key role in reducing uncertainty.
- articulate the
two core propositions underpinning an institution-based view of global
business.
- identify the
basic differences between democracy and totalitarianism.
- outline the
differences among civil law, common law, and theocratic law.
- understand the
importance of property rights and intellectual property rights.
- appreciate the
differences among market economy, command economy, and mixed economy.
- participate in
two leading debates concerning politics, laws, and economics.
- draw implications
for action.
General
Teaching Suggestions
Politics,
laws, and economics are fertile ground for heated debate. The Debates and
Extensions at the end of the chapter may give you some ideas for the
development of debate teams. If you regularly read the Wall Street Journal, you
will likely find something that might be used as a tool to bring out some
aspects of this chapter and might be effective simply because the topic is
current.
Opening
Case Discussion Guide
Emerging Markets: The Peril and Promise
of Russia. This case can yield
many questions for class discussion. It
covers the economic growth and development since the Soviet Union dissolved and
Russia became separate from the other Soviet republics. Although it does
mention corruption and loss of individual freedom in covering the extent to which
Russians are better off, much (not all) of the discussion focuses on economics.
Ask your students whether they feel that too much focus is placed on economic
betterment or not enough. Ask them if they would be willing to lose some
personal freedoms if the country where they live could enable them to enjoy a
better life financially?
Chapter Outline: Key Concepts and
Terms
Sections I through
VIII of Chapter 2
I. UNDERSTANDING INSTITUTIONS
1.
Key Concept
Institutions are commonly defined as “the rules of
the game.” Institutions have formal and
informal components, each with different supportive pillars.
2.
Key Terms
·
Cognitive
pillar
refers to the internalized, taken-for-granted
values and beliefs that guide individual and firm behavior.
·
Formal
institutions include laws,
regulations, and rules.
·
Informal
institutions include norms,
cultures, and ethics.
·
Institutional framework is made up of formal
and informal institutions governing individual and firm behavior.
·
Institution-based
view requires firms to constantly monitor, decode, and adapt to
the changing rules of the game to survive and prosper.
·
Institutions are popularly known as
“the rules of the game.”
·
Institutional
transitions
are fundamental and comprehensive changes introduced to the formal and informal rules that affect firms
as players.
·
Normative
pillar
refers to how the values, beliefs, and actions of other relevant
players—collectively known as norms
—influence the behavior of local individuals and firms.
· Regulatory pillar is
the coercive power of governments.
II. WHAT
DO INSTITUTIONS DO?
1.
Key Concept
The key functions of institutions are to reduce
uncertainty, curtail transaction costs, and combat opportunism.
2.
Key Terms
·
Institutional
transitions:
defined as “fundamental and comprehensive changes introduced to the formal and
informal rules of the game that affect organizations as players.”
· Opportunism: defined as
self-interest seeking.
·
Transaction
costs:
defined as costs associated with economic transactions—or more broadly, costs
of doing business.
III. AN INSTITUTION-BASED VIEW OF GLOBAL BUSINESS
1.
Key Concepts
Proposition 1: Managers and firms rationally pursue their interests and make choices within formal
and informal institutional constraints in a given institutional framework. Proposition 2: When formal
constraints are unclear or fail, informal constraints will play a larger
role.
IV. POLITICAL SYSTEMS
1.
Key Concepts
Democracy is a political system
in which citizens elect representatives to govern the country. Totalitarianism
is a political system in which one person or party exercises absolute political
control.
2.
Key Terms
·
Communist totalitarianism centers on a communist
party.
·
Democracy is a political system in which citizens elect
representatives to govern the country on their behalf.
·
Political risk—risk associated with political changes that may
negatively impact domestic and foreign firms.
·
Political system refers to the rules of the game on how a country
is governed politically.
·
Right-wing totalitarianism is characterized by its
intense hatred of communism.
·
Theocratic totalitarianism refers to the
monopolization of political power in the hands of one religious party or group.
·
Totalitarianism (dictatorship) is defined as a political system in which one person or party
exercises absolute political control over the population.
·
Tribal totalitarianism refers to one tribe or
ethnic group (which may or may not be the majority of the population)
monopolizing political power and oppressing other tribes or ethnic groups.
·
Political Risk involves risk associated with political changes
that may negatively impact domestic and foreign firms.
V. LEGAL SYSTEMS
1.
Key Concept
Civil law uses comprehensive
statutes and codes as a primary means to form legal judgments. Common law is
shaped by precedents and traditions from previous judicial decisions.
2.
Key Terms
·
Civil law uses comprehensive statutes
and codes as a primary means to form legal judgments.
·
Common law is shaped by
precedents and traditions from previous judicial decisions.
·
Copyrights are the exclusive
legal rights of authors and publishers to publish and disseminate their work.
·
Intellectual property specifically refers
to intangible property that results from intellectual activity (such as books,
videos, and websites).
·
Intellectual property
rights (IPRs) are
rights associated with the ownership of intellectual property. IPRs primarily
include rights associated with (1) patents, (2) copyrights, and (3) trademarks.
·
Legal system refers to the rules
of the game on how a country’s laws are enacted and enforced.
·
Patents are legal rights
awarded by government authorities to inventors of new products or processes,
who are given exclusive rights to derive income from such inventions through
activities such as manufacturing, licensing, or selling.
·
Piracy: The unauthorized use
of IPRs is widespread, ranging from unauthorized sharing of music files to
deliberate counterfeiting of branded products.
·
Property rights: The legal rights to
use an economic property (resource) and to derive income and benefits from it.
·
Theocratic law: A legal system based
on religious teachings.
·
Trademarks are the exclusive
legal rights of firms to use specific names, brands, and designs to
differentiate their products from others.
VI. ECONOMIC SYSTEMS
1.
Key Concept
A pure market economy is
characterized by laissez faire and
total control by market forces. A pure command economy is defined by government
ownership and control of all means of production. Most countries operate mixed
economies with a different emphasis on market versus command forces.
2.
Key Terms
·
Command economy: Under this system,
all factors of production should be government or state-owned and controlled,
and all supply, demand, and pricing are planned by the government.
·
Economic system refers to the rules of the game on how a country
is governed economically.
·
Market economy is a term referring to a system characterized by
the “invisible hand” of market forces: government takes a hands-off approach
known as the laissez
faire.
·
Mixed economy, by definition, is an
economic system that has elements of both a market economy and a command
economy.
·
State-owned
enterprises (SOEs)—firms that are at least 10% owned
by the state. A Sovereign wealth
fund (SWF) is a state owned
investment fund.
VII. DEBATES AND EXTENSIONS
1.
Key Concept
Three leading debates: (1) What drives economic development? (2) What
are the most effective and least disruptive institutional transitions toward
more market competition? (3) How to best measure political risk?
2.
Key Terms
·
Market transition
debate pertains
to how to make the transitions work
in a most
effective and least disruptive way.
·
Moral hazard refers to
recklessness when people and organizations (including firms and governments) do
not have to face the full consequences of their actions.
·
Path dependency: the present choices
of countries (as well as firms and individuals) are constrained by the choices
made previously.
·
Washington Consensus is a view centered on
the unquestioned belief in the superiority of private ownership over state
ownership in economic policymaking that is often spearheaded by two
Washington-based international organizations: the International Monetary Fund
and the World Bank.
VIII. MANAGEMENT
SAVVY
1.
Key Concept
Managers considering working abroad should
have a thorough understanding of the formal institutions before entering a
country. In situations where formal constraints are unclear, managers can
reduce uncertainty by relying on informal constraints, such as relationship
norms.
End-of-Chapter Guide
*Review Questions and Answers
*Critical Discussion Questions
and Answers
*Global Action
*Video Case
*Closing Case
Review
Questions and Answers
- ON CULTURE: Is there any
relationship between the culture of a given country and the extent to
which it will likely have a dynamic, growing economy? Are there cultures
that would be more likely to limit economic growth and even result in
poverty? Defend your answer.
Usually
there are multiple forces that impact on a given economy during a given period
of time. It could be argued that if one culture values competitive hard work
and change but another country’s culture looks down upon such things that such
values could impact on the economy to at least some degree. Some will disagree
and may point out that even if it does, that economic impact is not the only issue
in life.
- Compare PengAtlas
Maps 1.1 (Developed Economies and Emerging Economies) and Map 1.2
(Political Freedom Around the World). To what extent do developed
economies tend to have a high level of political freedom–or is there any
relationship? If there is a relationship, is it causal or coincidental?
Explain.
Map 1.1
lists 33 developed nations Map 1.2 lists countries as Free, Partly Free or Not
Free. Of the 33 developed nations, 32 are on the Free list and the remaining
nation (Singapore) is the on the Partly Free list. Most students will find it
difficult to believe that there in no relationship between being free and being
developed. However, China is listed as Not Free but is likely to eventually be
listed as developed – whether it will also eventually be on the Free or Partly
Free list remains to be seen.
- Compare PengAtlas
Map 1.3 (Legal Systems Around the World) and Map 1.1. In your opinion,
what stands out to you regarding each category of legal system? Are there
any relationships? If so, are they causal or coincidental? Defend your
answer.
Of the
20 countries with civil law, a majority (12 or 80%) are developed. Of the 16
countries that have common law, a majority (9 or 56%) are developed. The three countries with theocratic law are
not listed as developed. Since there
were far fewer theocratic law countries as compared to the other two
categories, it cannot be stated with certainty that there is or is not a
relationship between development and theocratic law. Furthermore, the numbers
20 and 16 are not large numbers. However, it does appear that a larger listing
of countries might indicate a relationship.
- How can the rules
of the game reduce uncertainty?
The very
word “rules” suggests the answer to that question. When there is nothing involving formal or
informal rules to serve as a guideline, there is obviously going to be
uncertainty.
- Do rules of the
game promote or prevent opportunism? Defend your answer.
Students
will probably argue that much depends on the rules.
- Do you agree that
managers and firms really pursue their interests? Why or why not?
It
probably could be argued that they pursue their interests but their idea of
what constitutes their interest may not be in agreement with what others would
regard as their interest. A firm or person may wish to be respected and admired
by society – that may be what the firm or individual feels is in one’s best
interest. However, that might involve not taking advantage of an opportunity
for increased profits or a raise in compensation.
- What are examples
of informal constraints that affect global business firms?
Students
should be able to list a variety of constraints such as the negative reactions
of various stakeholders to actions that may be legal but viewed as
unacceptable.
- What are the pros
and cons of expanding into a democratic country?
Various
responses may include less threat from an arbitrary dictator but there is the
risk that if the democracy does not have any constraints on what the majority
can do, a minority could be exploited by the majority – i.e. four foxes and one chicken voting on what to have for
supper.
- What are the pros
and cons of expanding into a totalitarian country?
At
first such a country might seem to offer stability. However, the pros or cons
of such an expansion could be affected by the extent that there is opposition
to the government in that nation and whether that could lead to an overthrow of
the government but also confiscation of your property? Another is to what
extent are there groups who might boycott your products if you do business in
that country?
- Would you rather
do business in a country that uses civil law or common law? Why?
Opinions
may vary depending on the extent to which one prefers flexibility versus
certainty. Some may prefer what is being
used in the country in which they live.
- What are some of
the issues to consider before doing business in a theocracy?
Cultural
sensitivity would be especially important in such a country. Familiarization with beliefs and the
application of those beliefs to all aspects of business would be essential.
- What is the
relationship between property rights and economic development?
According
to de Soto, there is a significant relationship between the two: The legal
protection of property rights allows for economic growth. For example, when
property rights are in place, an entrepreneur can use his or her title to a
piece of land as collateral for a small business loan.
- Why is it
important to protect IP rights?
IP is
normally intangible and can thus be easily duplicated. The incentive to invent or create music, etc.
could be reduced if innovators had no
assurance of reaping rewards from their efforts.
- Under what
circumstances would it be easier to do business in a command economy than
a market economy?
In a
market economy, one may need to convince many buyers but in a command economy
in which the government is the buyer, the persuasion needs to be directed only
toward those in control of the government. Also, buyers in a market economy may
be fickle and change their mind over time but in a command economy, there is
stability unless those in the government change what they want.
- Many view the
United States as a mixed economy. In your opinion, is the mix changing? If
so, how? Is it shifting more to a command economy or a market economy?
Defend your answer.
The U.S.
economy is constantly changing but in which direction may depend on the
political and economic tilt of those answering the question. Those who want
more government involvement may not feel that a specific increase in government
is sufficient and may take a much different view of the direction of the
economy than those who feel that the country is moving toward a command
economy.
- In your opinion,
which is most important to economic development—culture, geography, or
institutions? Defend your answer.
This is
a question in which the answer is not so important as the reasoning given and
the ability to defend that reasoning.
- Given whatever
plans you have for the future, do you feel you would have the greatest likelihood
of success under private ownership or state ownership? Why?
The
answer to this question may depend on the specific individuals career plans
(perhaps it involves some type of government activity, for example) and the
person’s social, political and economic tilt.
- Why is it
important to understand formal institutions before entering a country?
Explain by using an example.
This is
true for both firms and individuals who wish to avoid being fined or
imprisoned. Students should be able to create examples using their own country
that could get a person or firm into trouble if there was no awareness of
formal institutional requirements.
- ON CULTURE: Why is understanding of human relations within
a culture sometimes more important than legal expertise?
In some
societies there will be no need for legal expertise (for example, to prepare a
contract) until the relationship has been established so that one is trusted.
Critical
Discussion Questions and Answers
- How
do you explain your country’s economic success (or failure)?
Encourage
students to answer this question by focusing on concepts brought forth in this
chapter (political systems, laws, economic systems) and avoid using the
question to expound favor or opposition to a politician or ideology. However,
this is a question in which the answer is not as important as the thought
process and the ability to clearly articulate.
- What
is your view on the debate between private ownership and state ownership?
The
response will likely be the result of ideology but this
is a question in which the answer is not as important as the thought process
and the ability to clearly articulate.
- ON
ETHICS:
As manager, you discover that your firm’s products are counterfeited by
small family firms that employ child labor in rural Bangladesh. You are
aware of the corporate plan to phase out these products soon. You also
realize that once you report the counterfeiting to the authorities, these
firms will be shut down, employees will be out of work, and families and
children will be starving. How would you proceed?
This is
a question in which the answer is not as important as the thought process and
the ability to clearly articulate. However, since you plan to phase out the
product you may chose to ignore the counterfeiting. Even though child labor is involved, since
child starvation is worse, you might offer advice to the family firms as to how
to be more successful.
- ON
ETHICS:
Your multinational is the largest foreign investor and enjoys good profits
in Sudan, where government forces are reportedly cracking down on rebels
and killing civilians, and Vietnam, where religious leaders are reportedly
being prosecuted. As country manager, you understand that your firm is
pressured by activists to exit these countries. The alleged government actions,
which you personally find distasteful, are not directly related to your
operations. How would you proceed?
Although
this is also a question in which the answer is not as important as the thought
process and the ability to clearly articulate, there are some things that
should be considered even by students who really do not care about
social/humanitarian issues and are only concerned about the bottom line. In a
global economy with instant global communication of news, the policies of a
given country might not affect a firm’s operations in that country but it might
affect the firm’s sales and problems with legislative initiatives in other
countries.
GLOBAL ACTION
- Evaluating political risk is an important element of
country risk analysis. In fact, your personal interest relates to
countries in the Middle East and North Africa region that have a high
political risk. Provide a brief overview of the region and the reasoning
behind assessing these countries that have been assessed with high
political risk. From this list, which country has the highest overall
country risk?
Exercise
1 Answers
One resource which can be used is
“A.M. Best Country Risk Ratings”.
This website can be found by entering the search term “country risk analysis”
at the globalEDGE™ Resource Desk search box located at http://globaledge.msu.edu/resourceDesk/. Once at the A.M.
Best Country Risk Ratings website, click on the “AMB Country Risk Report:
Global Summary” link (located in the middle). Answers may vary based on the
specific report used (the September 2009 report was used for the purposes of
this exercise). After reading through the available report, the 5 countries in
the Middle East and North Africa which are indicated as high political risk
are: Egypt, Jordan, Morocco, Turkey, and Lebanon. To assess which country has
the highest overall country risk, each of these 5 countries can be related back
to the Country Risk Tier (CRT) list. As such, only Lebanon is listed in the lowest
category (CRT-5). Therefore, as of September 2009, Lebanon could be considered
to have the highest overall country risk.
Search
Term:
“country risk analysis”
Resource
Name:
A.M. Best Country Risk Ratings
globalEDGE™ Tag: Country Level
- Since you work for a diversified multinational
corporation, economic risk across different sectors of the world economy
is an integral part of analysis as it indicates the future business
prospects for specific industries. Evaluate the risk assessment of three
industry sectors that are available to analyze. Prepare a report and
provide a recommendation concerning which industry and region would be
most beneficial to your company.
Exercise
2 Answers
One resource which can be used is
“@rating”. This website can be found by entering the search term “different
sectors” at the globalEDGE™ Resource Desk search box located at http://globaledge.msu.edu/resourceDesk/. Once at the @rating
website, use the dropdown box for Sectorial Risk (located on the right side).
Answers may vary based on the specific industries chosen. However, if
Chemicals, Mass Distribution, and Pharmaceuticals are chosen, then the
evaluation may follow a specific format. The worldwide evaluation for each
sector is: Chemicals (B+), Mass Distribution (B+), and Pharmaceuticals (A-). In
general, this appears positive. In addition, the highest ranking regions (e.g.,
regions with low industry risk) for each region are as follows: Chemicals
(Middle East/North Africa and Japan), Mass Distribution (Middle East/North
Africa, CIS, Japan, Emerging Asia, and Latin America), and Pharmaceuticals
(Emerging Asia, North America, Western Europe, and Latin America). This may
lead to a discussion concerning the ideal regions for their company. For
instance, according to the analysis of the Chemicals, Mass Distribution, and
Pharmaceuticals industries, it would appear that the Middle East/North Africa,
Japan, and Latin America may be the most beneficial for the company.
Search
Term:
“different sectors”
Resource
Name:
@rating
globalEDGE™ Tag: Country Level
VIDEO
Case discussion guide and answers
Title:
India and China Economic Giants
RT:
3:28
Topic Key: Institution-based view, Global business, Formal institutions,
Political systems, Democracy, Totalitarianism, Communist totalitarianism,
Political risk, Property rights, Intellectual property rights, Patents, Piracy,
Economic system, Market economy, State owned enterprises, State ownership,
Private ownership
The video
opens with a ride on the Shanghai airport train in China which at 430 km/h and
270 miles/h is the world’s fastest. The moment you arrive in China, the country
shouts progress. China is out to prove a point by overtaking the world. The
video captures traffic beeping in India where it, too, is on a path for growth
and riches but it doesn’t’ look that way with some roads being the worst in the
world. Democracy has not delivered the transport infrastructure which India so
desperately needs. The narrator examines two individuals, one from China, Billy
Wang, and one from India, Tyron Toladi, for how it looks to them as they create
the new wealth.
Billy
Wang’s Shandbrai shoes tell the tale. His workers copy from photos of their
customer’s favorite shoes—all imitation not innovation. The business is
expanding very fast like all Chinese manufacturing. Mr. Wang, certainly,
doesn’t question the Chinese system which helps make him rich. Bill Wang says
(through interpretation) according to the Chinese way of thinking, the
political system is decisive—everything else is second to this. With ships in
the harbor, this way of thinking is evident when you see the big picture in
China too. Shanghai’s international port is largely one way traffic. China
doesn’t buy much overseas so many containers arrive empty but they go out
crammed full. China is selling hard. The world has good reason to worry.
China’s achievement is simply staggering. Single-minded, one party government,
making clear decisions means that China dominates the export world.
But in
India, young risk takes are not dismayed. Tyron Toladi, 22 years old, is so
confident that he cut short studies in American to create business in Mumbai—
high fashion accessories. He insists that India can beat China by combining
cheap labor with design skills—innovation not imitation. Tyron says we never
copy direct. We spend so much time consistently on how to make new products,
new designs, news things out there, finding new trends, and developing new
styles. In the big picture of India, skills drive heavy industry too. India
steel companies can’t compete with China’s bulk standard production so they
make only high value specialist steel meeting Europe’s most exacting standards.
This source of heavy industry is where India sees opportunity from massive
growth over the next 10 to 15 years. The Indians are convinced they have a huge
edge over China.
For Billy
Wang and Tyron Toladi, both countries are rising at a dizzying rate. But, it’s
clear India lags far behind for now. Democracy and the need for public consent
hasn’t delivered change so quickly. In China, where there is no need for
consent, the risk of major political upset seems much greater. The only
certainty is that both countries will race each other to overtake most of the
outside world.
Suggested
Discussion Questions and Answers
- What
impact do the political systems of each country have on their efforts
toward globalization?
- Text: A political system refers to the
rules of the game on how a country is governed politically. At the
broadest level, there are two primary political systems: (1) democracy
and (2) totalitarianism. Democracy is a political system in which
citizens elect representatives to govern the country on their behalf. A
fundamental aspect of democracy that is relevant to the effective conduct
of global business is an individual’s right to freedom of expression and
organization. The opposite end of democracy is totalitarianism (also
known as dictatorship), which is defined as a political system in which
one person or party exercises absolute political control over the
population. Totalitarianism, in general, is not as good for business as
democracy.
- China and Billy Wang: China and Billy
Wang’s efforts toward globalization will be determined by the
totalitarian government. From the video, Mr. Wang, certainly, doesn’t
question the Chinese system which helps make him rich because the
political system is decisive. Billy Wang’s decisions to globalize or do
any business at all will be dictated by what the communist government
says he must do. With a dictatorship/communist government in place,
political risk is much greater which could upset efforts to globalize or
do business internationally. However, decisions are made faster with only
one person in charge. As a result, China shouts progress.
- India and Tyron Toladi: India and Tyron
Toladi’s efforts toward globalization will be determined by their
democratic government. From the video, Mr. Toladi has the opportunity to
innovate and create new ideas within his business. Tyron Toladi’s
decisions to globalize or do any business is his choice. With the
democratic government in place, political risk is lower which invites
more globalization. However, decisions are made slower because of the
need for public consent which reduces the speed of change. As a result,
infrastructure problems hinder India’s progress toward globalization.
- How do IP rights differ between India
and China? What distinctive competencies in IP exist for India and China?
- Text: Intellectual property rights
(IPRs) are rights associated with the ownership of intellectual property.
IPRs primarily include rights associated with (1) patents, (2)
copyrights, and (3) trademarks.
- IPRs China: According to the video,
China is more about imitation that innovation. China is likely to have
fewer IPRs because they tend to counterfeit branded products. Their
distinctive competency is to create fake DVDs and Rolexes.
- IPRs India: According to the video,
India is more about innovation than imitation. India is likely to have
more IPRs because they create new products. Although not explicit,
India’s distinctive competency could be to establish more patents on
fashion accessories.
- Describe how India and China are market
economies.
o Text: An economic system refers to
the rules of the game on how a country is governed economically. A pure market
economy is characterized by the “invisible hand” of market forces first noted
by Adam Smith in The Wealth of Nations
in 1776. The government takes a hands-off approach known as the laissez faire. Specifically, all factors
of production should be privately owned. The government should only perform
functions that the private sector cannot perform (such as providing roads and
defense). A pure command economy is defined by a government taking, in the
words of Lenin, the “commanding height” in the economy. All factors of
production should be government-or state-owned, and all supply, demand, and
pricing are planned by the government. A mixed economy, by definition, has
elements of both market economy and command economy.
o China and India market economies:
Whether a country is communist or democracy, each one has government and
private sector intervention. Therefore, really, making them mixed economies.
Communist and Democracy countries claim to have a “market economy,” but the
meaning is different depending of the degree to which market forces are allowed
to organize their economies.
- Does India have an opportunity to
overtake China? Why or why not?
- Text: Economic development in different
countries is driven by culture, geography, and institutions.
- India Overtake China: India does have
the opportunity to overtake China. While China has a culture of smart and
hard working so does India. China may also have country-specific
resources but India does as well. In both accounts, India is superseding
China in true innovation. Using an institutional framework view, India
provides:
- Opportunity to grow and specialize to
capture gains from trade
- A strong, formal, market supporting
framework to trade on an informal basis
- Market supporting institutions to
protect property rights
Closing
Case discussion guide and answers
Emerging
Markets: The Future of Cuba covers the problem that the Castros have had with
economic ideology unable to overcome economic reality. It points to some benefits that have been
obtained since Fidel Castro established Communist control but also some of the
loss of economic capabilities that have occurred. It appears that Cuba may have
to relax controls and allow more economic and individual freedom. In addition
to questions below, you may raise the question as to why there should be any
problem since there is very little power in the hands of any who might oppose
the Communist system and the government can use the police and military to
force everyone to do what the government wants?
1. Why has state ownership of farms resulted in a
disaster in Cuban farming?
You can point out that there has been no problem that can be attributed
to weather or a change in soil. You can
further extend the question by pointing out that agricultural output was not a
big problem before the Castros took over. Furthermore, with the state in firm
control, supposedly things should be better organized to achieve higher levels
of production.
Theft from hungry people should not be a problem
with tight police control.
2. ON ETHICS: What are the norms governing employee
behavior in Cuban SOEs? Are these norms right or wrong?
Poverty and hunger can help create norms that will ease those problems
– but ask students if the “ends justify the means?” Ask them what they
would do if they worked for the SOE’s.
3. The Economist predicted that “whatever
the intentions of Cuba’s communist leaders, they will find it impossible to
prevent the island from moving to some form of capitalism.” Do you agree or
disagree?
Students’ opinions will vary.
4. Should foreign firms be interested in entering
Cuba?
You may ask students as to what criteria should be used in answering the
question. Should it be based on a
potential investment in Cuba providing greater profitability than other areas
of the world or should it be on the basis helping the poor? What if the poor
benefit only a very little but government officials benefit very much? What
about the risk that future leaders of government might repent of any flirtation
with capitalism and then seize the investments of foreign firms? Ask students
if there is a level of political and social change that should be obtained
before investment so that economic growth resulting from the investment does
not (as mentioned above) simply provide the funds to help maintain and entrench
those who now control the country?
http://www.mediafire.com/download/ubl5r84z4eo85qh/TB_Sample-274.zip |
No comments:
Post a Comment